The public procurement of information systems: dialectics in requirements specification
Journal article, Peer reviewed
MetadataShow full item record
Original versionEuropean Journal of Information Systems. 2017, 26 (2), 143-163 10.1057/s41303-017-0035-4
When acquiring information systems, public entities face a dilemma. On the one hand, they want to procure the system that best suits their needs, which often requires lengthy dialogues with vendors. At the same time, they are restricted by government regulations that mandate limited dialogue in the interests of transparency and equal opportunities for all vendors. To examine how public entities deal with this, we followed three procurement projects in Norway. We show that this dilemma manifests itself as a dialectic between the thesis of getting the system requirements right and the antithesis of strictly adhering to regulations. Public entities search for a resolution of this dialectic through two syntheses: selecting an appropriate tendering procedure, and learning how to specify requirements through networks of peer public entities. Our findings reveal that the syntheses are possible because the dialectic is actually complimentary, both the thesis and the antithesis are needed to create the joint outcome that satisfies both. The resolution of the dialectic unfolds differently over time. Our study contributes to the relatively neglected stream of IS research on dialectics that explicitly searches for a synthesis while revealing the complementarity of the dialectic. We show how time plays a nuanced role in the resolution of the dialectic situation.
JournalEuropean Journal of Information Systems
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Public procurement and firm performance : the effects of public procurement on firm performance in Norway Jin, Yi (Master thesis, 2019)This master thesis sheds light on whether there is positive relationship between public procurement and firm performance in Norway. Two hypotheses are proposed. Hypothesis 1 is that there exists a positive relationship ...
Benonisen, Monica; Strand, Marianne (Master thesis, 2020)This thesis uses simulation and regression analysis to investigate how different evaluation methods affect outcomes in procurement. In order to simulate the data, we have made our own algorithm in R Studio to answer our ...
Oil and gas service companies adapting procurement and sourcing to the volatile oil and gas market Monnac, Sophie Malmei (Master thesis, 2015)The purpose of this paper is to address the increasing importance of supply chain agility for oil and gas service companies. In a highly volatile and complex oil and gas industry, service companies are increasingly ...